Clean vs. Dirty Intermittent Fasting — Everything You Need To Know

There are two main types of intermittent fasting: clean and dirty. Both have their pros and cons, and depending on your goals and lifestyle, one may suit you better. This article delves into the differences between clean and dirty intermittent fasting, incorporating insights from experts like Dr. Frank O’Neill, to help you decide which method is right for you.

What Is Intermittent Fasting?

Intermittent fasting (IF) is an eating pattern that cycles between periods of fasting and eating. Various methods exist, such as the 16/8 method—fasting for 16 hours and eating during an 8-hour window—or the 5:2 method, where you eat normally for five days and restrict calories for two days. The best method depends on your lifestyle and schedule. Learn more about different fasting methods in our comprehensive guide.

Intermittent fasting has gained popularity due to its health benefits and effectiveness in weight loss. The two main types are clean and dirty intermittent fasting.

What Is Clean Fasting?

The term “clean fasting” refers to strictly adhering to traditional intermittent fasting rules, consuming only specific beverages during the fasting window.

During a clean fast, only calorie-free beverages like water, unflavored sparkling water, black coffee, and plain tea are allowed. While black coffee contains approximately 5 calories per cup, this minimal amount doesn’t break the fast. Adding sugar, cream, or milk introduces calories and shifts you into a dirty fast. Let’s explore the key characteristics of clean fasting.

Avoid these foods and drinks during the fasting window:

• Artificially or naturally sweetened products like flavored beverages, water additives, gum, mints, and breath sprays
• Flavored coffee
• Sweet or fruity flavors, including items marketed as “zero-calorie” or “low glycemic”
• Protein supplements such as BCAAs
• Bone broth

By avoiding these products, you prevent insulin release, allowing your body to access stored fat more efficiently. Clean fasting promotes ketosis and autophagy. Ketosis is a metabolic state where the body burns fat and ketones for energy instead of glycogen. Autophagy is the body’s process of recycling old and damaged cells, making way for new ones. To optimize fat burning and autophagy, it’s important to avoid anything that could disrupt these processes.

What Disrupts Ketosis and Autophagy?

Certain factors can disrupt ketosis and autophagy:

Insulin Spikes

Insulin is a hormone that moves glucose from digestion into tissues like muscles and the liver for energy. High insulin levels cause the body to use glucose for energy before tapping into fat stores, hindering fat loss—especially on a high-carbohydrate diet. Limiting foods and drinks that raise blood sugar levels is essential to promote fat burning.

Protein-Rich Foods

Protein-rich foods can stimulate insulin release and halt autophagy, including protein shakes and BCAAs. Excess protein can be converted into glucose through gluconeogenesis. Understanding the purpose of fasting highlights the importance of avoiding certain foods and drinks during the fasting window.

What Is Dirty Fasting?

Dirty fasting offers a more flexible approach, allowing minimal calorie consumption during the fasting window.

Traditionally, fasting means abstaining from all caloric intake. However, dirty fasting permits small amounts of calories—usually under 50 calories—to be consumed without significantly impacting insulin levels or disrupting the fasting state.

Fasting for weight loss limits carbohydrate and sugar intake, reducing insulin levels. As a result, hormones like glucagon and epinephrine rise, prompting fat cells to release stored fat. Some fats consumed may be converted into ketones in the liver, providing an alternative energy source for the brain.

By keeping calorie intake minimal and focusing on low-carbohydrate foods, dirty fasting aims to maintain low insulin levels, allowing the body to continue burning fat and producing ketones for energy.

What Can You Consume on a Dirty Fast?

Here are items you can consume in small amounts during a dirty fast:

• Artificial sweeteners like aspartame, Splenda, or stevia
• Small quantities of cream, 2% cow’s milk, or almond milk
• Minimal amounts of honey or maple syrup
• Bone broth
• Lemon or lime juice in water
• Apple cider vinegar
• Sugar-free gum and mints

You can add these to beverages for flavor. However, it’s crucial to keep your total caloric intake during the fasting window below 50 calories to avoid breaking the fast. Consuming more could trigger an insulin response and disrupt the fasting benefits.

Expert Insights: Dr. Frank O’Neill on Clean vs. Dirty Fasting

In his video “Clean versus Dirty Fasting Methods (Pros and Cons of Each),” Dr. Frank O’Neill discusses the nuances between clean and dirty fasting:

“A clean fast would be water—you can add salt or unflavored electrolytes—and black coffee or tea. Dirty fasting allows for minimal additions like a splash of milk in your coffee, artificial sweeteners, or sugar-free gum. The differences in benefits between clean and dirty fasting are much smaller than people might think.”

Dr. O’Neill emphasizes that while clean fasting may offer slight benefits, especially for maximizing health benefits beyond weight loss, the most important aspect is choosing a fasting method that you can sustain:

“Consistently good is always better than occasionally great. You have to find the fasting program that you can stick with that works best for you.”

He also points out that for some people, dirty fasting can make the fasting period more manageable without significantly impacting results:

“I lost 165 pounds in a year, and I was fasting dirty. I would have sugar-free gum or a diet soda when I was craving something. A few calories might slow you down, but quitting certainly won’t speed it up.”

Which Is Better—Clean or Dirty Fasting?

Both clean and dirty fasting can be effective, but the choice depends on your personal goals and how your body responds.

Clean Fasting:

• May offer slight additional health benefits like enhanced autophagy
• Eliminates the risk of accidentally breaking your fast due to calorie miscalculations
• Best for those seeking maximum health benefits beyond weight loss

Dirty Fasting:

• Provides more flexibility and may make fasting more sustainable for some
• Allows minimal calorie intake (under 50 calories) without significantly impacting insulin levels
• Can help manage hunger and cravings, making it easier to adhere to fasting schedules

However, some products allowed in dirty fasting, like artificial sweeteners, may cause digestive issues or other side effects, especially on an empty stomach. If you’re unsure about managing these factors, clean fasting might be the better option.

Can Dirty Fasting Be a Reason You’re Not Losing Weight?

Your ability to lose weight depends on various factors, including health, hormones, and metabolism—all influenced by your lifestyle and diet.

Dirty fasting might hinder weight loss if you inadvertently consume too many calories during the fasting window, breaking your fast and disrupting fat burning. As long as you keep caloric intake minimal—under 50 calories—you should remain in a fasted state. Dr. O’Neill notes:

“Every calorie does count at the end of the day. If you’re consuming 40 calories on your dirty fast and you fast every other day, it does add up over time.”

So, if you need a splash of milk in your coffee, it’s acceptable as long as you monitor the amount. Overconsumption is what transforms dirty fasting into something less effective.

Factors That Affect Weight Loss While You’re Fasting

Several factors can influence your weight loss results during intermittent fasting:

1. Sleep

Sleep is vital for weight loss success. Lack of sleep impairs your body’s ability to function optimally, reduces energy levels, and increases cravings. Research indicates that getting at least seven hours of sleep per night can boost metabolism, reduce appetite, and enhance fat burning. Insufficient sleep can also elevate cortisol levels, a stress hormone associated with weight gain.

Tips to improve sleep quality:

• Limit caffeine intake in the afternoon and evening
• Engage in regular physical activity
• Create a relaxing bedtime routine with dim lighting and calming activities
• Practice meditation or deep breathing exercises before bed

Improving sleep can significantly enhance your weight loss efforts.

2. Stress

Stress is linked to weight gain and can impede weight loss. High levels of cortisol due to stress encourage fat storage, especially around the abdomen, and increase cravings for unhealthy foods. Chronic stress can also lead to low energy levels and poor sleep, making it challenging to maintain a healthy diet and exercise routine.

Stress management techniques:

• Meditation
• Yoga
• Breathing exercises
• Short walks
• Listening to calming music
• Connecting with friends and family

Managing stress can improve your ability to lose weight effectively.

3. Medication

Certain medications can influence your weight loss journey. Some, like birth control pills, glucocorticoids, and certain antipsychotics, may cause weight gain or make it harder to lose weight by increasing appetite or causing fluid retention. On the other hand, some medications for diabetes or appetite suppressants might aid weight loss.

Consult your healthcare provider to understand how your medications might affect your weight loss efforts.

4. Hormones

Hormonal imbalances can significantly impact weight loss. Leptin and ghrelin regulate hunger and satiety signals; imbalances can lead to overeating or undereating. Elevated cortisol levels from stress increase appetite and cravings for high-calorie foods while slowing metabolism. Thyroid hormones also regulate metabolism, and abnormalities can hinder weight loss.

If you suspect hormonal issues, consult a healthcare professional for appropriate testing and guidance.

5. Age

Age can affect weight loss due to changes in metabolism, hormone sensitivity, muscle mass, and bone density. As you age, your metabolism may slow down, and muscle mass tends to decrease, reducing calorie-burning efficiency. Lower bone density can also affect digestion and calorie expenditure.

Incorporating strength training and maintaining an active lifestyle can help mitigate these effects and support weight loss at any age.

FAQs

Is dirty fasting effective?

Yes, dirty fasting can be effective as long as you keep your caloric intake below 50 calories during the fasting window to maintain a fasted state.

Is dirty fasting bad?

Not necessarily. Dirty fasting allows for minimal calorie intake, which can still provide fasting benefits. However, overconsumption or choosing unhealthy additives can negate the advantages.

Can you reach ketosis on dirty fasting?

Yes, you can reach ketosis during dirty fasting if your caloric intake is low and primarily from fats with minimal carbohydrates. Keeping total daily carbohydrate intake under 50 grams is crucial.

Summary

Intermittent fasting involves cycling between periods of eating and fasting and offers various health benefits, including weight loss. Clean fasting strictly limits intake to calorie-free beverages during the fasting window, while dirty fasting allows for minimal calorie consumption (under 50 calories).

Both methods can be effective, but clean fasting reduces the risk of accidentally breaking your fast. Dirty fasting offers more flexibility but requires careful monitoring. As Dr. Frank O’Neill advises:

“Practical beats perfect every time. Consistently good is always better than occasionally great.”

Ultimately, choosing between clean and dirty fasting depends on your preferences, lifestyle, and ability to manage your intake during fasting periods. The best fasting method is one that you can sustain and that helps you achieve your fitness goals.

References

1. Papatriantafyllou E, Efthymiou D, Zoumbaneas E, Popescu CA, Vassilopoulou E. Sleep Deprivation: Effects on Weight Loss and Weight Loss Maintenance. Nutrients. 2022 Apr 8;14(8):1549. doi: 10.3390/nu14081549. PMID: 35458110; PMCID: PMC9031614.

---