Skip to main content
Head-to-head record

Colleen Smith vs Melanie Rucker

Colleen Smith
Colleen Smith
0 2
2 head-to-head meetings
Melanie Rucker
Melanie Rucker
Athlete A
Colleen Smith
Colleen Smith
United States Women's Figure
Athlete B
Melanie Rucker
Melanie Rucker
United States Women's Physique
2 Shared Contests
2009 First Meeting
2010 Last Meeting
Query-derived Compiled from contest-result records and cached for performance; community flags are reviewed before any change. Updated August 8, 2026

Colleen Smith vs Melanie Rucker head-to-head record and every decided contest between them on record.

Meetings
2
Colleen Smith
0 ahead
Melanie Rucker
2 ahead
Span
2009–2010

Only 2 head-to-head meetings on record so far, with Melanie Rucker ahead 2 to 0 - too thin to call a rivalry yet.

Head-to-Head Meetings

Year Contest Division Colleen Smith Melanie Rucker Winner
2010 Masters Nationals Women's Figure #8 #5 Melanie Rucker
2009 North American Championships Women's Figure #13 #5 Melanie Rucker

Head-to-Head at Shared Contests

Colleen Smith
0
Wins Head-to-Head
2 shared contests
Melanie Rucker
2
Wins Head-to-Head

Attribute Tug-of-War

Each bar splits a metric by each athlete's share of their combined total. A centered bar means they are level.

Career Overlap Timeline

Shared Contest

Career Stats Comparison

Shared Contest History

Year Contest Division Colleen Smith Melanie Rucker Winner

Share This Comparison

Method

This page counts finishing positions

Every figure here comes from where each athlete placed in the contest record. Judging sheets and point spreads are not in the database, so a comparison tells you who finished higher on the night. It does not tell you by how much, or how close the call was.

  • A head-to-head result needs both athletes at the same contest in the same division. Two athletes on the same stage in different divisions were never judged against each other, so that show is not counted as a meeting.
  • Only contests both athletes actually entered can be settled here. Careers that never overlapped produce a side-by-side record and no head-to-head, because there is nothing to count.
  • Career totals cover the results we hold. A missing regional or amateur show lowers a total; it never invents one.
  • A shared placement is left as a tie. It is reported separately rather than split between the two athletes.

Cite / CSV / Embed

Browse all widgets →