Bodybuilding legend Jay Cutler is lending a hand to up-and-coming athletes in the IFBB Pro League. In a recent video (November 18, 2026), he revealed why he always judged how effective his workouts were based on soreness.
After finishing runner-up behind Ronnie Coleman four times, Cutler finally secured the Mr. Olympia title in 2006. His reign didn’t mirror ‘The King’s’; Jay ended up losing the crown in 2008 against Dexter Jackson. However, this gave him the mental fuel needed to pull off one of the biggest comebacks the sport had seen.
He won back Olympia gold in 2009 with his quad stomp pose and ultimately walked away with four victories at the prestigious event. At 53, his training approach has shifted from muscle building to longevity. In his latest effort, Cutler broke down why muscle soreness was the ultimate indicator of training performance.
Jay Cutler Reveals Why Muscle Soreness Was His Biggest Indicator of Workout Productivity
In the YouTube video, Cutler said he judged his workouts by how sore he was afterward. He added that if he wasn’t sore after training, it meant he didn’t go hard enough or didn’t eat properly.
“The only way I judged my workouts how productive they were is how sore I was. If I was not sore, then I wasn’t training hard enough or eating properly.”
Additionally, Jay emphasized that tissue work was key to better, more productive training sessions.
“I think we still are avoiding the therapy that is necessary. I would spend six hours a week with tissue work to keep the fascia loose. You know, a functioning muscle is always more productive,” shared Jay Cutler.
Cutler had proven strategies that helped propel him to the top of the Men’s Open. He recently outlined how he got shredded with just diet tweaks, rather than using harsh diuretics.
“I was just so I have to come in crazy condition. Remember, they were testing for diuretics then. So, I was like, okay, I got to figure out a way to be drier and harder, so I don’t have to manipulate as much at the end. I was doing that 50 grams of carbs stuff; that was my idea. It wasn’t Chris’ idea. No, he wasn’t really for it, but he was like hey, do what you want, but I’ll just keep an eye on you.”
From diet to optimal workouts, Cutler used every resource at his disposal to etch his legacy into stone. To this day, he believes soreness was the most meaningful indicator of training progress.
RELATED: Jay Cutler Explains Why You Should Always Train Triceps Before Biceps


