Jay Cutler Says ‘New Guard’ Have Invaded Men’s Open: ‘We’re Falling Back into That 90’s Era’

With shapely and aesthetic bodybuilders finding success in the Open class, Cutler weighed their impact and discussed 2023 Olympia.

Doug Murray
By
Doug Murray
Doug Murray is a News Editor for Fitness Volt with a focus on strength sports, including bodybuilding and powerlifting. His experience covering diverse sports, including MMA,...
7 Min Read
Jay Cutler on 2023 Olympia and 90s
Jay Cutler (Credit: Instagram YouTube: Cutler Cast)

Bodybuilding legend Jay Cutler is looking ahead at the upcoming 2023 Mr. Olympia contest taking place November 2-5. In a recent Cutler Cast podcast, Cutler discussed the Men’s Open division changing and who might emerge as the next Mr. Olympia. 

With two major bodybuilding events in the books, fans are beginning to take inventory of the new Open class hierarchy. At the 2022 Mr. Olympia competition, balance and conditioning prevailed as Hadi Choopan took home his first Sandow. Not only was Mamdouh ‘Big Ramy’ Elssbiay dethroned in fifth place, but fans were surprised by 212-turned-Open standout Derek Lunsford’s runner-up performance. 

Less than three months later, the 2023 Arnold Classic took over Columbus, Ohio for its 35th event. In the end, Samson Dauda claimed gold though fans were critical of the outcome and scorecards. Even some veterans of the sport like Chris Aceto and former Mr. Olympia Samir Bannout took issue with the perfect scores Dauda received in Ohio. 

In light of the controversy, event announcer Bob Cicherillo has taken to a few Voice of Bodybuilding podcasts to provide more details on the judge’s decision to award Dauda the win over Walker. He explained that Dauda had the best combination of factors such as shape, aesthetics, balanced proportions, conditioning, and symmetry.

Get Fitter, Faster

Level Up Your Fitness: Join our 💪 strong community in Fitness Volt Newsletter. Get daily inspiration, expert-backed workouts, nutrition tips, the latest in strength sports, and the support you need to reach your goals. Subscribe for free!

He also went as far as to say that Dauda at 100% would win the next Olympia contest. The latest to offer his thoughts on the 2023 Olympia is Jay Cutler, who is adamant that it will take a massive effort to defeat Hadi Choopan. 

Jay Cutler Breaks Down Top Threats to Hadi Choopan’s Mr. Olympia Title in 2023

Cutler said people are forgetting about Choopan and the dominant package he brought to Vegas a few months ago. However, he expects Big Ramy, Derek Lunsford, and Samson Dauda to be viable threats to ‘The Persian Wolf’s’ title on the horizon. 

Hadi is going to be very difficult to beat. People forget quick man, you know,” said Jay Cutler. “You guys got to remember, he’s knocked at that door and he kicked that thing in. Not even – you know a better overall look, but not what he is capable of. Yeah, I think so too [he’ll be better]. I think Derek is going to be tremendously better and Samson peaked once already this year… it’s tough. And Nick Walker is even more hungry now.” 

As someone who made a successful bodybuilding comeback, Cutler believes Ramy still has a shot at regaining his Mr. Olympia status. He added that Lunsford’s rear poses are some of his best and that it makes him an even more dangerous threat. 

“Listen, I think Ramy can still come back and win this thing, you know. I mean, we forget about – where’s Brandon Curry fall in this? What if Brandon has time down and comes in. Remember, he was beating down the door for a couple of years straight.” 

“Dude, Derek is very dangerous in that spot too. I mean, who’s going to beat him in the rear poses? Who’s going to be him in front double biceps. You think Samson can beat him in a front double? Derek has the lats and the small waist and that front double that’s just bananas,” Cutler shared. “He [Andrew Jacked] doesn’t have the lat taper that Derek has.” 

Cutler on Men’s Open Changes: ‘We’re Falling Back Into That 90s Era’ 

Given how competitive the Men’s Open division has become, Cutler believes the category is starting to reflect the 90’s era of bodybuilding, which saw many aesthetic bodybuilders make their name in the sport, like Flex Wheeler, Shawn Ray, and Chris Cormier

Get Fitter, Faster

Level Up Your Fitness: Join our 💪 strong community in Fitness Volt Newsletter. Get daily inspiration, expert-backed workouts, nutrition tips, the latest in strength sports, and the support you need to reach your goals. Subscribe for free!

“I’m just thinking as you guys are conversing, and I think we should probably close it out on this because we talked a lot about the Arnold. We’re falling back into that 90s era of competitive

Some interactive features require JavaScript. Core data on this page loads without it.

Data updated

The world's most complete bodybuilding resource

News, contest results, rankings and free tools, built on 108,000+ recorded results since 1946.

22,218
Athlete records
108,576
Competition results
2,386
Contests
81
Seasons, 1946 to now
147
Countries represented
UPCOMING Mr. Olympia 2026

The Mr. Olympia Returns

Full results, qualifications & live leaderboard

00
Days
00
Hrs
00
Min
00
Sec
Explore Olympia 2026
12
Divisions
LIVE
Leaderboard

Bodybuilding News

Latest Results

This Day in Bodybuilding

September 7
2024
IFBB Heart of Texas Pro Euless, TX, USA
2023
Chris Bumstead Announces Retirement Plans Chris Bumstead hinted at potential retirement from Classic Physique competition after achieving five consecutive Olympia titles, sparking widespread discussion about the future of the division.
See All Events

Who holds the Olympia titles

Crowned at the 2025 Olympia.

2026

Road to Olympia 2026

Track every athlete racing for Olympia qualification. Live standings across all 11 Olympia-qualifying divisions, updated after every contest.

OP CP MP BK FG WL WP FT 212 WT MS
View Standings

Built on Official Contest Results

22,000+ athletes, 2,000+ contests, 108,000+ results - all free and searchable

All Divisions

Click any division to browse athletes and contest history

Greatest Athletes of All Time

Ranked by Olympia titles. Athletes level on titles are all shown, so a tab can run past six.

The arguments, answered

Head-to-head placings from contests both athletes actually entered, in the same division. Every one of these is a record, not an opinion.

  • Kevin Levrone or Nasser El Sonbaty?

    Kevin Levrone leads 23-10

    Meetings
    33
    At the Olympia
    8
    Span
    1992-2002

    What it cannot settle: their meetings run from 1992 to 2002, 11 seasons. That compares two careers across time, not two athletes at their peak.

    See every meeting
  • Branch Warren or Victor Martinez?

    Branch Warren leads 7-6

    Meetings
    13
    At the Olympia
    7
    Span
    2004-2015

    What it cannot settle: it was close. The trailing athlete still took 6 of the 13, so one different night changes who leads.

    See every meeting
  • Kevin Levrone or Shawn Ray?

    Kevin Levrone leads 7-4

    Meetings
    11
    At the Olympia
    10
    Span
    1992-2001

    What it cannot settle: their meetings run from 1992 to 2001, 10 seasons. That compares two careers across time, not two athletes at their peak.

    See every meeting

Questions we ran the whole record against

Each of these is computed from every qualifying result on file, not from a sample and not from anybody's recollection. The finding is stated in full below; the study page shows the working, the year-by-year series and the coverage it was computed over.

Computed from the Fitness Volt bodybuilding database on . Each study page states the rows its own figure was computed over.

What bodybuilding is, and what this page holds

Bodybuilding is a sport judged on how a physique looks, not on what it lifts or how fast it moves. Competitors train and diet toward a single day, present the result on stage in a fixed set of mandatory poses, and a panel of judges places them first to last. No clock runs and no lift is recorded. Judges rank rather than score, their placings are added up, and the lowest total wins, which is why a winning number on a scorecard looks small.

The sport is split into divisions, and the division decides what the judges are looking for. Men's Physique marks extreme muscularity down. Classic Physique holds competitors to a maximum weight for their height. Men's Open sets no weight limit at all. Each division has its own pose list, its own attire rule and its own scoring split, so an athlete who wins one can place nowhere in the next.

Two titles organise the professional calendar. The Mr. Olympia has run every year since 1965 and is the one every pro season points at; athletes reach it by winning or placing at sanctioned pro shows through the year. The Arnold Classic, first held in 1989, is the title that comes next.

This page is the way into our record of all of it: 108,000+ placings from 2,000+ contests, covering 22,000+ athletes, the oldest from 1946. Every figure below is derived from those results, and where a detail was never published we leave it blank rather than fill it in.

When each division reached the Olympia stage

The Olympia began as one contest for one division and took on the rest a few at a time. Each year below is the first Olympia our record holds a champion for in that division.

The first Olympia each IFBB Pro League division was contested at, oldest first.
First Olympia Division
1965 Men's Open Bodybuilding
1980 Women's Bodybuilding
1995 Women's Fitness
2003 Women's Figure
2008 Men's 212 Bodybuilding
2010 Women's Bikini
2013 Men's Physique
2013 Women's Physique
2016 Men's Classic Physique
2018 Men's Wheelchair
2021 Women's Wellness

These are Olympia debuts, not the years the divisions were created. A division is normally contested at other pro shows for a season or two before the Olympia takes it on, so a year here can sit later than the date a federation gives. Women's Fit Model has no Olympia edition on record at all, so it has no year here.

About competitive bodybuilding results

Fitness Volt covers professional and amateur bodybuilding competition, including the Mr. Olympia, Arnold Classic, international IFBB Pro League shows, and NPC events.

Its twelve IFBB Pro division pages are built from recorded contest results and athlete histories.

The Men's Open Bodybuilding division is the flagship category, the one Larry Scott won at the first Olympia. Classic Physique uses height-based weight limits and emphasizes proportions, aesthetics, and condition.

The women's side includes Bikini, Figure, Wellness, Women's Physique, Women's Fitness, Women's Bodybuilding, and Women's Fit Model.

Every athlete profile includes their full competition history, division breakdown, Olympia appearances, and head-to-head records. Use the compare tool to see how any two athletes stack up across their careers.

Frequently Asked Questions

There are currently 12 active IFBB Pro League divisions: Men's Open Bodybuilding, Men's 212 Bodybuilding, Men's Classic Physique, Men's Physique, Men's Wheelchair, Women's Bodybuilding, Women's Physique, Women's Figure, Women's Bikini, Women's Wellness, Women's Fitness, and Women's Fit Model.

Where this data comes from

Every figure on this page is computed from the recorded competition results, so the totals always match the contests behind them. The records themselves are checked by hand, and corrections are made against the sources named on each contest page.

Placings come from federation listings for modern contests and from historical sources for earlier eras, and each contest page names the source behind it.

Where a detail is not on record it is left blank rather than estimated. A missing height, a missing birth date or a missing venue means we do not have it, not that the athlete lacks one.

The panel below counts source records, which is a different figure from the corpus totals in the bar at the foot of this page. An athlete is counted there once for every source that documents them, and an athlete no named source documents does not appear in it at all. The distance between the two numbers is our source coverage, and publishing it is the point of the panel.

Dataset citation

Cite the Bodybuilding Database

Dataset version .

Suggested citation: Fitness Volt Bodybuilding Database, v2026-09-07

About the Database API documentation

  • Athletes: 376,677 source records, 109,674 linked athletes, 42 named sources.
  • Contests: 10,349 source records, 6,717 linked contests, 22 named sources.
  • Results: 526,031 source records, 337,203 linked results, 12 named sources.
Live corpus
  • 22,218 athletes
  • 2,386 contests
  • 108,576 results
  • 147 countries
  • 1946 to 2026

Data updated

– ‘oh this guy could be here,’ we’re still not talking about Hunter Labrada who I feel could be in the mix. I mean, these are people that we just – there’s a lot of excluded people that we’re still excited about. Is Sergio going to come back? Yeah. I mean, there’s so many guys.” 

“We’re excited about an Open class which I think fell off for a minute because the old guard was coming out, going out, and now the new guard has come in and a lot of new guys are like solidifying position now. It’s making it exciting again.” 

Cutler isn’t the only bodybuilder taking a closer look at how the Arnold Classic affected the division. Nick Walker joined Nick Trigili and Guy Cisternino recently to discuss judging and the controversial outcome in Ohio. Walker was under the impression that conditioning wins contests but stressed judges might be starting to favor shape and aesthetics more than size and conditioning. 

RELATED: IFBB Judge Terrick El Guindy: “If Nick Walker Never Ever Wants to Lose to Samson Dauda, Get Those Legs Bigger”

With approximately eight months until the next Mr. Olympia contest, fans are excited to see who will push into title contention. As for Cutler, he’s happy to see the Men’s Open division thriving again like it was in the 90s. 

Watch the full video below: 

Relive every moment from the 2025 Mr. Olympia, including prejudging, highlights, expert analysis, and full results. Explore our Olympia hub: FitnessVolt.com/olympia. For minute-by-minute coverage, follow our Live Blog.


If you have any questions or need further clarification about this news, please leave a comment below, and Doug will get back to you as soon as possible.

Share This Article
Follow:
Doug Murray is a News Editor for Fitness Volt with a focus on strength sports, including bodybuilding and powerlifting. His experience covering diverse sports, including MMA, for publications like Sportskeeda and CagesidePress informs his in-depth reporting.
Leave a Comment